Research and Advances
Computing Applications Research highlights

Technical Perspective: The Strength of SuRF

  1. Article
  2. References
  3. Author
  4. Footnotes
Read the related Research Paper

Data structures that filter data for point or range queries are prevalent across all data-driven applications, from analytics to transactions, and modern machine learning applications. The primary objective is simple: find whether one or more data items exist in the database. Yet, this simple task is exceptionally difficult to perform efficiently, and surprisingly critical for the overall properties of the data-intensive applications that rely on filtering.

This is a hard problem as there are numerous critical parameters and trade-offs. Many parameters come from the workload, for example, the exact percentage of point queries versus updates, percentage of empty-result queries, and so on. Other parameters come from the underlying hardware; for example, filters typically reside in memory but, with exponentially increasing data sizes, we need to be mindful of the filter size and the memory hierarchy. Overall, there are complex trade-offs to navigate: memory, read, and write amplification. For example, a data structure cannot be efficient for both point and range queries while also supporting efficient writes. Yet, numerous applications need to expose both read patterns.

A prototypical application of filters is storage engines based on Log-Structured Merge Trees (LSM-tree). An LSM-tree stores data in the order they arrive in immutable files and periodically sort-merges them into larger files. This way, it behaves in between a log and a sorted array, providing a good balance of read and write performance depending on the exact tuning (file size, buffer size, among others). LSM-tree storage engines are used as the backbone of most distributed key-value stores and applications range from social media, Web-applications, e-shopping, IoT, and so on. Due to their multilevel architecture enforcing a global temporal order, LSM-tree engines rely heavily on in-memory filters.

The trie-based design (of SuRF) enables the construction of a filter that can support performant range queries, point queries, and approximate counts.

Succinct Range Filter (SuRF) was introduced at the ACM SIGMOD 2018 Conference as a new succinct filter.1 SuRF is based on a trie-like structure termed "Fast Succinct Trie." The trie-based design enables the construction of a filter that can support per-formant range queries, point queries, and approximate counts. The authors of SuRF make the following critical and insightful observation that brings everything together and allows SuRF to balance the various hardware and workload trade-offs. For a given set of queries, the upper levels of the trie incur many more accesses than the lower levels. For this reason, the SuRF design utilizes a dense, performance-optimized encoding scheme for the top of the trie and a sparse, memory-optimized encoding scheme for the bottom. This results in a data structure that is both fast and memory efficient. The upper levels, which are comprised of few nodes but incur many accesses, encode keys under a new scheme called LOUDS-Dense which sacrifices space efficiency for fast lookups. The lower levels, which contain the majority of nodes but have a sparser access pattern are encoded with a scheme called LOUDS-Sparse, which sacrifices fast lookups for space efficiency.

Compared to state-of-the-art bloom filter-based solutions (for example, prefix bloom filters) SuRF provides a general solution, that is, it can support any range query as well as efficient point queries. Compared to state-of-the-art tree or trie-based solutions The trie-based design enables the construction of a filter that can support performant range queries, point queries, and approximate counts. SuRF offers similar or better performance at a much smaller memory footprint. The SuRF paper that follows shows end-to-end impact by integrating SuRF in RocksDB, the most mature LSM-tree based storage engine, and demonstrating strong results (for example, up to 5x) in time-series applications for both point and range queries. SuRF can be applied broadly to any application that needs a succinct filter such as monitoring, privacy/security, and graph analytics. Finally, the core spirit of the design of SuRF exemplifies elegant research taste in pursuing hybrid, hardware-and workload-conscious designs.

    1. Zhang, H., Lim, H., Leis, V., Andersen, D.G., Kaminsky, M., Keeton, K. and Pavlo, A. SuRF: Practical range query filtering with fast succinct tries. In Proceedings of ACM SIGMOD 2018.

Join the Discussion (0)

Become a Member or Sign In to Post a Comment

The Latest from CACM

Shape the Future of Computing

ACM encourages its members to take a direct hand in shaping the future of the association. There are more ways than ever to get involved.

Get Involved

Communications of the ACM (CACM) is now a fully Open Access publication.

By opening CACM to the world, we hope to increase engagement among the broader computer science community and encourage non-members to discover the rich resources ACM has to offer.

Learn More