Sign In

Communications of the ACM

[email protected]

Bringing More Women, Immigrants, to Computer Science


View as: Print Mobile App ACM Digital Library Full Text (PDF) In the Digital Edition Share: Send by email Share on reddit Share on StumbleUpon Share on Hacker News Share on Tweeter Share on Facebook
BLOG@CACM logo

http://bit.ly/2PHmm8O April 26, 2019

In March we celebrated Women's History month, but there were few female computer scientists to celebrate. Women receive only 16% of U.S. bachelor's degrees in pure computer science (CS). In an age when women outnumber men in medical schools, we scratch our heads when we see such a small number. What's going on? The National Center for Women & IT (NCWIT) reports: "By 2026, 3.5 million computing-related job openings are expected. At the current rate, only 17% of these jobs could be filled by U.S. computing bachelor's degree recipients." More women graduating in CS will reduce the magnitude of the looming crisis.

ACM launched a pioneering effort to address plummeting graduation rates in the early 1990s with the creation of a Council on Women in Computing (ACM-W). ACM-W seeks to recruit, retain, and celebrate women in computing.

I joined ACM-W in 2000, bringing with me a community-building idea for women in computing. In 1996, I used the fledgling Internet to count the numbers of female computer science majors in Indiana. Small pockets of women dotted the state. I dreamed of uniting these small groups of Indiana women by inviting them to attend a regional conference where each woman would find role models and a peer community. Attendees could build confidence by giving short "lightning talks" and poster presentations. The conference would dispel the myth of the lonely programmer hidden away in a cubicle by offering keynotes and panel presentations that share accurate career information. Women could find job and internship opportunities offered by industry and graduate school sponsors, who also serve as role models.

My colleagues and I organized the first conference, called an ACM Celebration, in Indiana in 2004. We imagined organizing Celebrations all over the world, so that no woman would feel isolated. Fast-forward 15 years, and ACM Celebrations now span the globe: Serbia, Chile, Ukraine, Canada, Philippines, Pakistan, Ireland, Turkey, Spain, and India, to name a few.

ACM-W Student Chapters sustain energy after one Celebration ends and before another begins. The ACM-sponsored organizations provide local activities on a smaller scale, but with the same Celebration mission to recruit, retain, and build community for women.

Beyond Celebrations and Chapters, what can institutions do? DePauw University awarded 47% of its computer science degrees to women in 2017—almost three times the national average. How? A lineup of traditional methods such as mentoring and role-modeling added new computer science majors, as did more specialized techniques like our CS Try-out. We invite every first-year woman (immediately before registration) to a preview of the introductory class, where third- and fourth-year female majors (and role models) sit alongside attendees to teach all that is needed to complete the first laboratory. The student teachers also talk briefly about their computing opportunities and career plans. Many women have zero computing experience, so the event removes the mystery surrounding computing classrooms and careers, as the older students describe their internship and research opportunities and their classroom projects—especially their impressive senior projects.

Finally, what can individuals do? We underestimate the power of encouragement, in my opinion. Once I heard a young woman tell an audience, "I am a computer scientist today, because of three words that a professor wrote on my exam." In response to a recent post on my Facebook page, a woman wrote, "And here, just this past week, I once again happened upon my first CS1 exam upon which Gloria had written, 'CS Major????'" (Ashley had saved the exam for 15 years). I encourage all of my talented students—both men and women. Woman after woman later tells me (as these two did) how my words influenced her. The number of men who have expressed the same sentiment? Zero!

This story is bittersweet. It's sad that women hunger for words of encouragement and value notes that take seconds to write. At the same time, this story about encouragement tells us how we—as sisters, brothers, mothers, fathers, partners, teachers, and other mentors—can change girls' and women's lives.

An important time to encourage girls is in elementary school. These very young girls have as much interest in computing and technology as young boys do. There's no unimportant time to encourage, because girls begin to lose interest as they progress through middle school and high school. Support the many worthwhile programs that target girls and college women. Above all, use only supportive language when talking with girls and young women about computing.

Back to Top

Sheldon Waite: Immigrants Help Solve the Looming STEM Worker Shortage

http://bit.ly/2Y0APQh April 12, 2019

As an engineering hardware manager working in the rapidly growing automotive electronics industry, I've been baffled by politicians who champion anti-immigration policies. If we want our economy to prosper, we should eagerly welcome the world-class talent that's knocking at our door.

I should know. I've witnessed firsthand the excellence newcomers bring to this country. About half of my 30-person engineering team is comprised of foreign-born workers or children of recent immigrants. As a hiring manager, I have recruited the best, assembling a whip-smart, talented group that keeps us on the cutting edge of a highly competitive field.

Car companies like Mercedes-Benz and Ford hire us to make hightech accessories for their cars, such as screens, radios, embedded cellphones, and Wi-Fi devices. As connectivity devices become more integral to the car industry, demand for our work continues to rise. I have worked in this industry for more than 15 years and see how important diversity is to staying ahead of the competition. The type of work we do is highly technical, but also creative, because we are always trying to solve problems. That's why the diverse perspectives on my team are so critical to helping us find out-of the-box solutions faster. Additionally, many of our bilingual employees give us a competitive advantage in the global economy. I'm proud to work alongside colleagues who work every day to make safer cars that improve consumers' lives.

I have heard people say they want to restrict immigration because they fear immigrants will take our jobs. But in my experience, there are not enough American-born workers to fill all these jobs. I just looked through a stack of résumés for summer internships, and the vast majority of applicants were immigrants or first- and second-generation Americans. This is emblematic of a broader trend: immigrants play a large role in science, technology, engineering, and math—or "STEM"—fields. In my home state of Illinois, for example, 24.1% of STEM workers were born in another country, according to a New American Economy analysis of various 2017 datasets (https://www.newamericaneconomy.org/locations/illinois/).

It is difficult to overstate this importance because employment in STEM jobs has grown significantly, exceeding overall job growth (https://pewrsr.ch/2UUpyPA). From 1990 to 2016, STEM occupations have grown 79%, with computer jobs increasing 338% over that same period, according to the Pew Research Center (https://pewrsr.ch/2vv5gBN). These fields are expected to play a critical role in future U.S. economic growth.

In my state–Illinois–the labor market for tech talent is tighter than that on the coasts. That is why I support policies that help keep these skilled workers right here, where they can contribute to the workforce and the economy. In Illinois alone, immigrants contribute $17.6 billion in taxes, include 118,055 entrepreneurs, and employ 390,685 people (http://bit.ly/2DJtvRr). Nationally, they pay $405.4 billion in taxes, account for nearly 3.2 million entrepreneurs, and create approximately 8 million jobs (http://bit.ly/2vtCYb5). If our country's policies send the message "we don't want you here," then where will all this talent go? To foreign competitors.

I am lucky to have a team of talented engineers, but I know the tech industry as a whole struggles to find the skilled workers it needs. The recent spate of anti-immigration policies doesn't help their case. The H-1B visa program, which is the main way U.S. companies hire high-skilled foreign workers, is capped at 65,000 visas, plus an additional 20,000 visas for foreign applicants with a U.S. graduate degree (http://bit.ly/2VDzoK4). Demand for these workers in recent years far exceeds the available number of visas. Last year, nearly 200,000 people applied (http://bit.ly/2vyg5De), and for the past six consecutive years, the H-1B visa cap has been reached within a week of the application period opening (http://bit.ly/2PCMS3a). And existing H-1B visa holders are grappling with the looming possibility the program allowing their spouses to work is on the chopping block (http://bit.ly/2J8teuO). This presents just another incentive to move to a country that is more inclusive.

Immigrants play a critical role in filling labor gaps; we should be embracing them. That means reversing policies that deter the hiring of foreign-born workers, creating a more streamlined immigration process, and cultivating a more supportive environment for newcomers.

Increasing immigration is the key to keeping our economy thriving. And the great thing about America is that people want to come here. So let's welcome them with open arms.

Back to Top

Authors

Gloria Townsend is a professor, and department chair of computer science, at DePauw University in Greencastle, IN, USA.

Sheldon Waite is an engineering hardware manager in Chicago's Northwest suburbs.


©2019 ACM  0001-0782/19/07

Permission to make digital or hard copies of part or all of this work for personal or classroom use is granted without fee provided that copies are not made or distributed for profit or commercial advantage and that copies bear this notice and full citation on the first page. Copyright for components of this work owned by others than ACM must be honored. Abstracting with credit is permitted. To copy otherwise, to republish, to post on servers, or to redistribute to lists, requires prior specific permission and/or fee. Request permission to publish from [email protected] or fax (212) 869-0481.

The Digital Library is published by the Association for Computing Machinery. Copyright © 2019 ACM, Inc.


Comments


Peter Contos

Agree with Ms. Townsend and I believe this change is already in progress. We'll see a greater percentage of women in computing jobs in near future.
Disagree totally with Mr. Waite. The H1-B visa program only suppresses wages for non-American workers and employs foreigners (here and abroad). Has he not heard about Disney IT workers that were laid off and forced to train their cheaper foreign replacements (under the guise of Disney sub-contracting IT operations). Ever hear of IBM? Or the hundreds of other stories about American IT workers displaced by lower wage foreigners, for example: https://www.computerworld.com/article/2883897/so-cal-edisons-path-to-the-center-of-the-h-1b-debate.html. Almost every week there is new story of the same. There are sufficient engineers, computer scientists and tech workers right now to fulfill the job market without adding a glut of H1-B visas.


Displaying 1 comment