Sign In

Communications of the ACM

BLOG@CACM

Teaching Programming To A Highly Motivated Beginner


I recount what I learned from spending nine months teaching computer programming to a person with no prior programming experience.


Comments


Anonymous

So basically if you're a genius (MIT's OCW on programming is far from being for beginners, and if he understood any of it he's nowhere near being one), spend 10+ hours a day on a skill and spend loads of money on a professional tutor then you can learn ? Interesting attempt at trying to guise it under 'highly motivated', but someone like yourself could never know what it's like for *real* beginners to learn a complicated discipline. It's easy to take credit when you're teaching the A+ class, but put you with some averages or remedials (note that neither of those are choices. No one chooses to not understand) and you'll fall flatter than a pancake under an 18 wheeler.

Nice try though, and the article does make some nice points. I just dislike the dishonesty (unintentional, but present everywhere) of when I read 'beginner' and then find something else. Especially when you brush everyone else off as them being 'unmotivated/not as motivated' to glorify those abnormal and vain standards. Is the article really about the learning process or teaching? No. It's about you holding the hand of someone who would have done it either way because he already knew how but just had some insecurities.

And who knows what I'll get brushed off as for my thoughts, if they even make it through the submission process for not being another +1 to everyone else's. I have more extensive knowledge on the beginner learning processes and know the problems real people have with it. It's sad to see these hyped up student dolls that you and everyone else use as a standard for everyone to meet when they're just exceptions that you all take in because you know that they won't require any serious work on. Students that would actually challenge you as an educator to do something for, now that would be someone I'd like to read about. But the doll that does everything himself with the magical power of 'motivation' alone and only asks for a bit of the "guru's guidance" wins yet again.


Anonymous

Vygotsky. Look up his learning theory if you aren't familiar with it. He proposed that we have ZPD's, zones of proximal discourse. Basically, they are how far the 'flashlights' of our understand reach out into what we are trying to learn. A teacher should try to get a student to see out as far as possible (the struggle) but not step into the darkness (that baffling). That way the student takes the biggest 'steps' possible toward learning part of the field.

I learned .NET with a multi-tiered database project, just because my organization had VB.NET, but no license for VB6. That was Framework 1.1. Even today I look back on some of that code and wonder how I ever got that far, basically just from the online help. What is more, some of the problems I was solving ended up having similar solutions in later versions of the Framework (of course, those are better tested, more efficient solutions, but still...) If real estate is location, location, location, then learning is motivation, motivation, motivation.


Anonymous

should take this to TED....


Anonymous

Fantastic post. Like Brian, I am a computer programming beginner myself. And this post is great motivation and encouragement. Thanks for this Phil.


Displaying comments 11 - 14 of 14 in total

Comment on this article

Signed comments submitted to this site are moderated and will appear if they are relevant to the topic and not abusive. Your comment will appear with your username if published. View our policy on comments

(Please sign in or create an ACM Web Account to access this feature.)

Create an Account

Log in to Submit a Signed Comment

Sign In »

Sign In

Signed comments submitted to this site are moderated and will appear if they are relevant to the topic and not abusive. Your comment will appear with your username if published. View our policy on comments
Forgot Password?

Create a Web Account

An email verification has been sent to youremail@email.com
ACM veriŞes that you are the owner of the email address you've provided by sending you a veriŞcation message. The email message will contain a link that you must click to validate this account.
NEXT STEP: CHECK YOUR EMAIL
You must click the link within the message in order to complete the process of creating your account. You may click on the link embedded in the message, or copy the link and paste it into your browser.